Article Word Count

User Interface (UI) / User Experience (UX) · Articles & templates · Created by Graylion
declined
article word-count writing

What functionality is missing? What is unsatisfying with the current situation?

  The current article word count includes tags, hidden comments and CSS formatting. For a lot of superusers or heavy writers they would not even bat an eye at this, I mean 3500 words or 3600 words.
 

How does this feature request address the current situation?

  This feature request highlights how important this will be for new user on-boarding who may not realize how everything works and for a user that just expects something to work. I am recommending a couple of approached below I know you will have better ideas.
  1. Remove as much superfluous words from the words count as possible to true-up the word count. Keeping in mind I am not recommending that the words count be absolutely 100% accurate only closer. The CSS styling box should be removed from the word count. The BBCode word count will most likely be much harder. Maybe known tags like bold, h1, h2, /* etc. But this I trust the expertise of the World Anvil Forge Master.
  2. Separate the word count displayed at bit for example ...   Example One
  • Content Words 628
  • CSS Words 100

  •   Example Two
  • Content Words 628
  • Main Content 528
  • Sections 100
  • CSS Words 100

  •  

    What are other uses for this feature request?

      This request is less about the exact method for doing this and more about showing the interest in this. So please in your comments post ideas and feedback to make this feature request shine.
     

    Notes

      This feature request would be considered a follow-up on this feature from October of 2021. This feature request had the following stats which shows a significant interest but not enough to reach the threshhold, and I think we can do even better!
     
  • 119/300 Votes · +19390 points
  • GitHub Ticket #1164

    Follow up


    A lot of these were fixed/updated with this GitHub ticket.
    Current score

    24/300 Votes · +4904 points

    Votes Cast

    • +1

      by Ormalin
      on 2022-07-15 20:38
    • +100

      by Tijmuhn
      on 2022-07-15 19:53
    • +100

      by JoellaKay
      on 2022-07-15 18:52
    • +100

      by Kwyn Marie
      on 2022-07-15 18:17
    • +300

      by TheDoctor292
      on 2022-07-15 18:01
    • +300

      by Stormbril
      on 2022-07-15 17:17
      Yes, please, CSS and scrapbook counting towards the wordcount is something that always bothers me!   I really like the examples of breaking it down into words per type, too.
    • +300

      by Jarissa
      on 2022-07-15 16:58
    • +300

      by WantedHero
      on 2022-07-15 16:38
      ...what Tillerz said x2
    • +100

      by Eliora Yona
      on 2022-07-15 15:30
      I do have a habit of editing and writing all at once. It's a nasty habit I need to break, but it would make things even just a little easier if the count didn't include BBC/CSS. I'm not sure how this could be fixed, but I hope it can be solved for ease of use - especially for those who are new and don't know about it.   Nonetheless, thank you Dimi and Janet for all you do - as well as the rest of the Inner Sanctum. You guys make things much easier on the two!
    • +100

      by LoreMoth
      on 2022-07-15 15:22
    • +1

      by P-47 Thunderbolt
      on 2022-07-15 15:13
    • +100

      by Lyraine Alei
      on 2022-07-15 14:43
    • +100

      by Michael Chandra
      on 2022-07-15 14:18
    • +300

      by PrippyMontyPoppyCock
      on 2022-07-15 14:09
      I would dread the thought if it was my responsibility to implement this, yet it would still be a great feature to have.
    • +300

      by Tillerz
      on 2022-07-15 13:37
      I mean if this is all complicated stuff and blabla serverload and whatnot... I'd even be happy if there was a client side attached to a button, so that I could just click it to get an accurate word count. I don't need word count while I type. Just every other paragraph I'd like to see where I am at, without going to preview, marking all, copy it and paste it into a proper online word count page.
    • +300

      by Kummer Wolfe
      on 2022-07-15 13:22
      To add, word count is currently impacted by what is both the scrapbook of the article and the gamemaster/storyteller hidden block. It would be nice if that was tallied separately.   When I write up session reports, I use word count to determine ease of reading. Knowing the actual word count of the article without the extra would help that a lot.
    • +1

      by A Mischievous Dryad
      on 2022-07-15 12:38
      Me, a clown, who didn't know about this and didn't use custom-css to win worldember last year
    • +300

      by Satrium
      on 2022-07-15 12:20
    • +300

      by Buzzard
      on 2022-07-15 11:06
      There is a plug-in for the tinymce editor that provides this functionality. Perhaps it could be adapted and/or provide some inspiration. I suspect that having this feature dynamically counting words on the editor side might be too complex. Maybe an actual word count could be calculated server-side and added to the article metadata on the presentation side.
    • +300

      by Toblin
      on 2022-07-15 10:28
      It would also save judges from having to copy-paste the entire article (in presentation mode) to a separate wordcounter for judging. You could just have Worldanvil do that for them with the improived, internal counter. Yes, please.
    • +300

      by Wordigirl
      on 2022-07-15 10:13
      Yes. I, too, believe the word count module should be updated. Perhaps eliminate all words between brackets? Count tagged articles as "one word" (or don't count them at all)? Another suggestion would be (and I'm not sure how hard this would be to implement) somehow put the word counter on the published page rather than in the editor? Have it scan all the words on that side of the article? Regardless of what solutions may be in store, I would love to see this improved. God bless and thanks for suggesting!
    • +300

      by Scalenex
      on 2022-07-15 08:57
    • +300

      by Mochimanoban
      on 2022-07-15 08:46
    • +1

      by Vibeca
      on 2022-07-15 08:45
    • +300

      by Graylion
      on 2022-07-15 08:14